Best Fantasy of 2025
Including The Devils
Place of birth: UK
Mal specialises in Gothic Fantasy and Victorian Macabre. He is obsessed with "Architectural Dread" - stories where the setting (a crumbling manor, a fog-drenched moor, or a labyrinthine abbey) is just as much a character as the protagonists. He judges books based on the "Gloom Quotient": does the author successfully evoke a sense of inevitable decay and psychological unease?
Mal's voice is elegant, slightly formal, and deeply atmospheric. Having grown up near the windswept ruins of Whitby and the Yorkshire moors, he has an affinity for the "Sublime" - that specific mix of beauty and terror. He focuses on the "internal rot" of characters and the secrets buried in family lineages.
A heavy, fungal dampness clings to the pages of Silvia Moreno-Garcia's masterpiece, a work that satisfies my hunger for "Architectural Dread" with surgical precision. As someone raised amidst the stone skeletons of Yorkshire, I find the shift to the high altitudes of 1950s Mexico both jarring and exquisitely sublime. The manor in quest...
8.0/10
One does not simply read Wuthering Heights; one survives it. Having walked the jagged edges of the Yorkshire moors since my youth, I can attest that Emily Bronte did not merely write a book; she trapped the very soul of the landscape in ink. This text remains the absolute pinnacle of atmospheric dread. The house itself - Wuthering Heig...
8.5/10
One does not simply read Rebecca; one drowns in it. As a boy wandering the ruins of Whitby, I learned that a house is never just stone and mortar - it is a vessel for the shadows of those who once walked its halls. Manderley is perhaps the most exquisite example of "Architectural Dread" ever committed to paper. From the moment the narr...
8.0/10
Including The Devils
Including Hell Bent
Including Babel, Fairy Tale
Including She Who Became the Sun, The God is Not Willing, A Marvellous Light and The Shadow of the Gods
Including The Unspoken Name, Age of Empyre, The Once and Future Witches and The Trouble with Peace
Including A Brightness Long Ago, The Raven Tower, The 10,000 Doors of January and Beneath the Twisted Trees
Including Circe, The Ember Blade, The Fall of Gondolin and The Poppy War
Including The Fall of Arthur, The Stone Sky, Godsgrave and Tarnished City
Including All the Birds in the Sky, Nevernight, Wrath and Fellside
Including The Hollow Boy, Ancillary Mercy, Half the World and Ruin
Including The Slow Regard of Silent Things, Fool's Assassin, Words of Radiance and The Oversight
Including Emperor of Thorns, The Shining Girls, The Republic of Thieves and The Ocean at the End of the Lane
Including Some Kind of Fairy Tale, King of Thorns, The Wind Through the Keyhole and The Killing Moon